ESG is asking: What Comes Next?

One question captures the shift in ESG over the past year: ESG is not going away. The question for businesses has simply changed from “Have you taken action?” to “What comes next, and what has that action achieved?”Over the past few years, companies have followed a familiar formula to demonstrate their commitment to sustainability: publish reports, pursue ratings, announce targets, and reinforce the message with a long-term vision. Today, however, this approach is no longer enough.Management teams want to understand how sustainability investments contribute to business performance. Customers want to know whether emissions data can be provided and verified. Regulators, meanwhile, are refining disclosure requirements while reassessing which companies fall within their scope.

China, Europe, and Taiwan are each taking a different regulatory approach, but their developments can be summed up in three observations:

  • China: The first year of mandatory disclosure is complete. The next challenge is ensuring that reporting remains consistent, accurate, and substantive.

  • Europe: Fewer companies are required to publish sustainability reports, but supply chain data requests are not declining.

  • Taiwan: Mandatory disclosure thresholds have been raised, but customer and market expectations remain unchanged.

This article examines these developments through policy updates and corporate practices across the three markets. It then explores two practical questions: What should companies do after publishing their first sustainability report? And what should businesses prepare for when entering international markets, where requirements often come from customers and financial institutions?

China: The First Round of Mandatory Disclosure Is Complete. The Next Challenge Is Data Consistency.

 

The first round of mandatory disclosure has been completed. What will distinguish companies going forward is their ability to maintain consistent reporting and ensure that their data can withstand scrutiny.

Under the Sustainability Reporting Guidelines issued by China’s Shanghai, Shenzhen, and Beijing stock exchanges, companies included in the SSE 180, STAR 50, SZSE 100, and ChiNext indices, as well as companies listed both domestically and overseas, were required to disclose their 2025 sustainability reports by April 30, 2026.

According to data from the China Association of Listed Companies, as reported by China National Radio, all 430 companies subject to mandatory disclosure submitted their reports on time. More than 2,700 A-share companies had published sustainability reports, representing 49.0% of the market, an increase of 3.5 percentage points from the same period a year earlier.

Disclosure requirements are also becoming more detailed. On January 30, 2026, the stock exchanges released revised implementation guidelines. In addition to general requirements and climate change, the updated guidance introduces specific disclosure topics covering pollutant emissions, energy use, and water resource management.

At the national level, nine government departments, led by the Ministry of Finance, issued the Corporate Sustainability Disclosure Standard No. 1 – Climate (Trial) in December 2025. Companies may adopt the standard voluntarily until its formal implementation scope is established. How the national standard and stock exchange guidelines will be aligned remains subject to further official clarification.

Completing the Report Is Only the Beginning

 

Data from China Securities ESG Rating, as cited by China National Radio, indicates that among companies disclosing for the first time, approximately 100 saw their overall ratings improve by nearly 10 points, while around 30 experienced declines of more than five points. Of the latter group, 20 failed to maintain continuous annual disclosure throughout the rating period.

This suggests that publishing a report once is only the starting point. Reporting continuity and the strength of internal data management are increasingly reflected in external assessments.

NIO: Moving from Data Collection to Measurable Management Improvements

 

In a public interview, an ESG representative from NIO described the company’s progress in three stages: first demonstrating that relevant initiatives were in place, then ensuring data accuracy, and now showing that identified issues can be addressed in ways that create tangible business value.

After a report is completed, the question from management is no longer simply whether a target has been included. It is how that target will be achieved.

To support this process, NIO has established an ESG data platform that integrates existing financial records and invoices. Its team reviews data anomalies monthly, reducing the need to collect information manually from different departments at year-end.

Upstream supplier data remains a significant challenge. Even when suppliers complete questionnaires, it can still be difficult to determine whether the information provided is accurate and reliable.

Regulations determine which companies must report. The ability to maintain reliable data over time determines whether those reports can withstand scrutiny.

Europe: Reporting Requirements Are Narrower, but Supply Chain Expectations Remain

 

The EU has narrowed the scope of companies required to report on sustainability, but market expectations have not disappeared.

In February 2026, the EU’s Omnibus I simplification package was officially published in the Official Journal of the European Union, significantly reducing the number of companies subject to mandatory sustainability reporting.

Under the revised Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), companies are generally required to meet both of the following thresholds: more than 1,000 employees and net annual turnover of at least €450 million.

The Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) has also been revised, with the scope narrowed to companies with more than 5,000 employees and annual turnover exceeding €1.5 billion. Its application date is set for July 26, 2029.

EU companies will begin reporting from financial year 2027, with the first reports due in 2028. On July 3, 2026, the European Commission also adopted a simplified version of the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), reducing the number of disclosure requirements. The revised standards must still undergo scrutiny by the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union, so the final version has yet to be confirmed.

A Narrower Regulatory Scope Does Not Mean Fewer Supply Chain Questions

 

The key issue lies in the supply chain.

Under the revised framework, companies with fewer than 1,000 employees within the CSRD reporting value chain may decline requests for information that go beyond the scope of the Voluntary Sustainability Reporting Standard for SMEs (VSME). This effectively establishes a boundary for sustainability data requests made to smaller businesses.

However, this provision primarily addresses information requests related to CSRD reporting. It does not restrict additional data requirements agreed upon through commercial contracts.

Large companies still need to pursue their decarbonization targets and demonstrate sustainability performance to investors. As a result, information requests that once came through regulatory reporting may increasingly appear in procurement requirements, supplier questionnaires, and customer assessments.

Henkel: Corporate Sustainability Targets Eventually Reach Suppliers

 

Henkel is a major German consumer goods and industrial group, with businesses spanning beauty and personal care, laundry and home care, and adhesives technologies. Its scale places it well above the revised reporting thresholds.

The company’s annual sustainability statement declares compliance with ESRS requirements. On April 14, 2026, Henkel also published a voluntary Sustainability Impact Report.

The report outlines 12 targets and 15 commitments through 2030. These include supplier sustainability standards, with a stated goal of having 85% of suppliers meet the company’s requirements. The quantitative figures in the company’s press release and report differ slightly, so the original report should be used as the primary reference when citing this target.

On climate action, Henkel aims to reduce Scope 3 emissions by 30% by 2030, compared with its 2021 baseline. The company reports that emissions have already declined by 28%.

Henkel identifies raw materials and packaging materials as major sources of its emissions. This means that meaningful reductions depend heavily on working with suppliers across the value chain.

For large companies, changes in regulation do not automatically alter their publicly stated sustainability commitments. Those commitments ultimately translate into specific expectations for suppliers.

Taiwan: Higher Mandatory Disclosure Thresholds, but Market Expectations Remain

 

Taiwan has adjusted the scope of companies required to adopt IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards, giving some businesses more time to prepare. However, customer and supply chain expectations are unlikely to ease as a result.

On September 23, 2026, Taiwan’s Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) and the Ministry of Environment announced adjustments to the implementation scope for listed and OTC-listed companies.

The original plan covered 1,970 companies across three phases. Under the revised arrangement, the third phase now covers companies with paid-in capital between NT$2 billion and NT$5 billion, together with entities designated by the Ministry of Environment.

The number of companies in the third phase has been reduced from 1,726 to 316, bringing the total number of companies across all three phases to approximately 560.

According to Taiwan’s Central News Agency, these 560 companies account for more than 87% of the total market capitalization of listed and OTC-listed companies, as well as approximately 96% of their greenhouse gas emissions. The revised approach therefore concentrates mandatory disclosure on companies with greater market presence and environmental impact.

The implementation timeline remains unchanged:

  • Phase 1: Companies with paid-in capital of NT$10 billion or more, beginning with financial year 2026.

  • Phase 2: Beginning with financial year 2027.

  • Phase 3: Beginning with financial year 2028.

Several transitional measures have also been introduced. During the first two years, Phase 3 companies will only need to disclose climate-related information, with other sustainability topics added in 2030. Scope 3 emissions disclosure will become voluntary. During the first two years of adoption, companies may submit their sustainability section together with their annual report up to 14 days before the shareholders’ meeting. Assurance requirements have also been narrowed.

Media reports differ in their descriptions of the revised assurance scope. The exact changes will need to be confirmed once the FSC formally updates the relevant annual report preparation regulations and notices. The FSC is expected to complete the revisions by the end of 2026.

Companies Outside the Mandatory Scope Still Need to Assess Their Own Priorities

 

Approximately 1,400 companies with paid-in capital below NT$2 billion that are not designated by the Ministry of Environment will no longer fall within the mandatory disclosure scope.

According to an analysis by Taiwan-based think tank Yunxun Think Tank, these companies are still expected to disclose basic information on climate governance, risk management, and Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. The FSC is expected to provide simplified reporting examples and encourage voluntary adoption through ESG evaluation incentives.

These details currently rely primarily on a single source and should be confirmed against the FSC’s formal documentation.

For these companies, regulatory pressure has clearly eased. However, businesses that had already planned their IFRS sustainability reporting schedules based on the original mandatory timeline now need to reconsider their next steps. Whether to maintain the original schedule, postpone implementation, or adjust the scope of disclosure is a decision each company must make.

Pegatron: Customer Requirements Travel Down the Supply Chain

 

Pegatron offers a clear example of how customer expectations are passed through the supply chain.

The company states that its targets have been validated by the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi). It aims to reduce Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions by 42%, and Scope 3 emissions by 25%, by 2030 compared with its 2021 baseline.

Company executives have publicly noted that the 25% Scope 3 reduction target has the greatest impact on the supply chain. Customers expect Pegatron to achieve this reduction, and Pegatron applies similar expectations to its own suppliers.

In 2023, the company launched its Carbon Data System Development and Supply Chain Low-Carbon Transformation Program. The initiative supported seven key suppliers in implementing 41 emissions reduction projects, achieving a cumulative reduction of 14,265 tonnes of CO₂ equivalent. It also assisted 23 suppliers in completing Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas inventories.

All figures above are based on company disclosures, with related reporting published in 2025.

Regulatory changes may reduce a company’s legal reporting obligations, but they do not remove the data and decarbonization requirements set by customers during procurement.

For Companies That Have Already Published a Report: Five Questions to Ask Next

 

Publishing a sustainability report does not mark the end of the process. It is the beginning of ongoing scrutiny from management, customers, and investors.

The latest developments across the three markets can be summarized as follows:

Market
Current Scope
Key Timeline
Status as of November 2026
Europe
CSRD: More than 1,000 employees and net annual turnover of at least €450 million. CSDDD: More than 5,000 employees and annual turnover exceeding €1.5 billion.
CSRD from financial year 2027; CSDDD from July 26, 2029.
Directives published in the EU Official Journal in February 2026. Simplified ESRS adopted by the European Commission on July 3, 2026; subsequent review remains pending.
China
430 companies subject to mandatory disclosure, including designated index constituents and companies listed both domestically and overseas.
2025 sustainability reports due by April 30, 2026.
Stock exchange guidelines are in effect. The Ministry of Finance's climate standard remains voluntary during the trial period.
Taiwan
Approximately 560 companies within the mandatory scope, based on paid-in capital thresholds and entities designated by the Ministry of Environment.
Phase 1 from financial year 2026; Phase 3 from financial year 2028.
Adjustments announced on September 23, 2026. Relevant regulations are expected to be revised by year-end.

Although the three markets have different regulatory scopes and implementation schedules, the questions raised by management, customers, and investors are increasingly similar.

The following five questions can serve as a practical checklist for reviewing an existing ESG program.

1. Is Every Publicly Announced Target Assigned to Someone?
 

Every target disclosed in a sustainability report should have a clearly designated owner, a baseline year, and an assessment of the resources required to achieve it.

Once a target becomes public, management will want to know whether it is achievable over the next five or ten years, how much investment it will require, and whether the current management structure can support it.

If baseline data has not yet been established, companies can begin by documenting completed inventories and ongoing initiatives rather than rushing to announce quantitative targets.

For percentage-based targets, such as reducing electricity consumption per employee by 1% to 2% annually, both the baseline year and target year should be clearly stated so that progress can be measured.

2. Is Data Collected Only at Year-End, or Is It Part of Daily Operations?
 

The examples of NIO and Pegatron demonstrate the importance of integrating ESG data collection into routine business processes rather than treating it as a year-end reporting exercise.

Companies that have not yet established a data platform should first clarify who is responsible for submitting, reviewing, and verifying information. Only then should they consider implementing a digital system.

Once responsibilities and workflows are clear, the system can serve a practical purpose.

3. Can the Company Respond Promptly to Customer Requests for Product Carbon Footprint Data?
 

Taiwan has made Scope 3 disclosure voluntary for companies in the third phase, while the EU’s VSME framework establishes boundaries for certain data requests to smaller suppliers. However, large customers may still require emissions information as part of their procurement processes.

Companies that already have a foundation for product carbon footprint accounting should organize their calculation methodologies, system boundaries, data sources, and underlying assumptions into a document that can be shared externally.

This allows the company to respond more efficiently when customers request information, rather than having to reconstruct the data each time.

4. Does the Report Distinguish Between Completed Results and Ongoing Initiatives?
 

Our understanding is that European regulation of environmental claims is becoming more stringent. Companies must therefore ensure that reported achievements and commitments are supported by appropriate evidence.

For documents intended for European markets, it is advisable to distinguish clearly between completed results, ongoing initiatives, and future targets.

This helps prevent work still in progress from being presented as an achieved result, while reducing the risk of misunderstandings in external communications.

5. Are Publicly Announced Timelines and Reporting Boundaries Still Aligned with the Latest Requirements?
 

Annual reporting plans originally developed around mandatory implementation phases may now fall under voluntary arrangements. Companies should reassess whether to maintain the original schedule, postpone implementation, or revise the reporting scope, and explain the rationale in their next report.

For groups with multiple brands, newly acquired subsidiaries, or multiple operating locations, it is also important to specify which entities and sites are included in the inventory and report, which are not, why certain areas are excluded (such as physical retail stores), and when they are expected to be included.

If the current Scope 3 inventory covers only selected categories, companies should clearly identify which categories have been included and outline the next steps for expanding coverage.

The assurance report date, reporting period, and information presented in the main report should also remain consistent.

Together, these five questions assess whether ESG targets have clear ownership, whether the supporting data is reliable, and whether public commitments can be translated into sustained action.

For Companies Planning to Expand Overseas: The Real Threshold Often Comes from Customers and Financial Institutions

 

The requirements businesses face when entering international markets do not always come directly from local regulators. For many suppliers, the actual thresholds are set by buyers, project developers, banks, and investors.

In a public interview, the ESG representative of a solar energy company noted that some major overseas projects include ESG requirements in their contracts. Companies without the necessary management systems may even be excluded from project participation.

The location of a project does not necessarily determine where its requirements originate. A solar power plant may be built in the Middle East or Africa, while its financing institutions, banks, or developers are based in Europe. These stakeholders may still require suppliers to provide information on carbon footprints, supply chain traceability, and labor rights.

This example reflects the experience of one interviewee in the solar industry and should not be generalized to every sector. Nevertheless, it highlights an important consideration: companies entering overseas markets need to understand the expectations of their customers and financial partners, and prepare the relevant information in advance.

Build an ESG Information Pack That Can Be Shared with Customers

 

The EU’s Omnibus framework provides smaller suppliers with the Voluntary Sustainability Reporting Standard for SMEs (VSME) as a reference for responding to sustainability information requests.

It remains unclear whether the protections associated with this framework also apply to suppliers outside the EU. Companies preparing to work with European customers should therefore confirm the specific requirements with their customers or legal advisers.

Even where the framework does not directly apply, businesses can use VSME as a reference when organizing their information. A consistent set of documents can then be used to respond to requests from multiple customers.

A practical ESG information pack should include:

  • Organizational boundaries: The scope of the company and relevant subsidiaries, together with the principles used to determine reporting boundaries.

  • Greenhouse gas emissions: Scope 1 and Scope 2 inventory methodologies, data sources, and results.

  • Product carbon footprint: Calculation methodologies, system boundaries, data sources, and relevant international standards.

  • Supply chain management: Supplier codes of conduct, supply chain management mechanisms, and implementation records.

  • Labor and human rights: Policies and management practices related to labor rights and human rights.

  • Data limitations: Areas not yet covered, current data limitations, and plans for future improvements.

Product Carbon Footprints Are Becoming an Important Procurement and Negotiation Tool

 
The same interviewee noted that products with lower carbon footprints may have opportunities to achieve price premiums in overseas markets. European customers, in particular, may consider overall product value rather than focusing exclusively on the lowest price.

This reflects the experience of one company. Whether the same approach applies to other products depends on customer profiles, procurement criteria, and market competition.

What is clear is that product carbon footprint data supported by a complete and transparent calculation methodology can help companies respond more effectively to customer assessments and procurement requirements.

When properly prepared, this information can become an important reference in pricing, evaluation, and contract negotiations, rather than remaining just another figure in a sustainability report.

For companies preparing to enter international markets, establishing a complete, verifiable, and reusable ESG information pack is far more effective than responding to customer questionnaires on an ad hoc basis.

Conclusion: What Remains When the Tide Recedes

China has completed its first round of mandatory sustainability disclosure. Europe has narrowed the scope of companies required to report. Taiwan has raised its mandatory disclosure thresholds.

The rules are evolving differently across these markets, but none has abandoned ESG.

What has changed is where expectations are expressed. They now extend beyond regulatory disclosure forms into buyers’ procurement requirements, financial institutions’ due diligence processes, and management’s ongoing questions about how sustainability targets will be achieved.

The presentation of a report still matters. But what will ultimately be tested is whether companies can provide consistent data, demonstrate progress against their targets, and substantiate their sustainability performance to external stakeholders.

As the focus moves beyond the number of reports published and ratings achieved, attention returns to the details of everyday operations: a unit of electricity consumed, a data sheet completed by a supplier, the person responsible for a public commitment, and information that customers can independently verify.

The next phase of ESG will not be defined by how much companies write, but by whether they can consistently deliver on what they have promised.

If your company is preparing for or reviewing its ESG disclosures, we welcome the opportunity to connect and exchange perspectives.

Share the Post: